Tact Filters

[pne]

Someone (I think damned_colonial or dotaturls) linked to a page on "tact filters" a while ago, but I misplaced the link. I found it again today through an entry in geeketiquette.

Executive summary: some of the differences in communication "strategies" between geeks/nerds and "normal people" can be explained by the concept of a "tact filter" which is installed in different directions in each set of people.

Tact Filters

I came up with this idea several years ago in a conversation with a friend at MIT, who was regularly finding herself upset by other people who worked in her lab. The analogy worked so well in helping her to understand her co-workers that I decided to write it up and put it on the web. I've gotten quite a few email messages since then from other people who have also found it helpful.

---

All people have a "tact filter", which applies tact in one direction to everything that passes through it. Most "normal people" have the tact filter positioned to apply tact in the outgoing direction. Thus whatever normal people say gets the appropriate amount of tact applied to it before they say it. This is because when they were growing up, their parents continually drilled into their heads statements like, "If you can't say something nice, don't say anything at all!"

"Nerds," on the other hand, have their tact filter positioned to apply tact in the incoming direction. Thus, whatever anyone says to them gets the appropriate amount of tact added when they hear it. This is because when nerds were growing up, they continually got picked on, and their parents continually drilled into their heads statements like, "They're just saying those mean things because they're jealous. They don't really mean it."

When normal people talk to each other, both people usually apply the appropriate amount of tact to everything they say, and no one's feelings get hurt. When nerds talk to each other, both people usually apply the appropriate amount of tact to everything they hear, and no one's feelings get hurt. However, when normal people talk to nerds, the nerds often get frustrated because the normal people seem to be dodging the real issues and not saying what they really mean. Worse yet, when nerds talk to normal people, the normal people's feelings often get hurt because the nerds don't apply tact, assuming the normal person will take their blunt statements and apply whatever tact is necessary.

So, nerds need to understand that normal people have to apply tact to everything they say; they become really uncomfortable if they can't do this. Normal people need to understand that despite the fact that nerds are usually tactless, things they say are almost never meant personally and shouldn't be taken that way. Both types of people need to be extra patient when dealing with someone whose tact filter is backwards relative to their own.

---

Reflections on this Essay after Ten Years

During the ten years since I wrote up the Tact Filter theory and put it on the (then fledgeling) web, I've gotten quite a bit of fan mail about it. I've been tempted to make some minor edits (such as substituting "geek" for "nerd"), but I think that's better left to this addendum.

Related Links

• Fanspeak, originally posted to rec.arts.sf.fandom in 1999 by Cally Soukupa, and mirrored on Karl Musser's website.
• Ozark English, posted by Suzette Haden Elgin in her LiveJournal.

---

Copyright © 1996, 2006 by Jeff Bigler. Permission is granted to redistribute this text in its entirety, provided that this copyright notice and either the URL for the page (http://www.mit.edu/~jcb/tact.html) or a link to it is included. All other rights reserved.

Comments

[kait-the-great.livejournal.com]

That's great. Thanks for sharing that. That's how I feel a lot of the time :)

[fledchen.livejournal.com]

Interesting. I'm going to repost this (with attribution to the original author, of course) as a Nerd Theory entry.

[nondescript.livejournal.com]

I, too, feel that I need to improve my outgoing tact. This post makes me realize that I, too, am a nerd. :P

[zompist.livejournal.com]

I think that's a nice way of saying that nerds have lousy social skills.

The problem with the analysis is, I think, that nerds often don't apply tact to incoming messages. They're offended and combattive if you talk to them the way they talk to others.

Not that all nerds are prickly, but many are. (And if they're not in person, they are on Usenet.)