Most prolific commenters on this journal

[pne]

A meme that's going around right now...

Total comments: 10652

1	pne		2889
2	nik_w		347
3	elgrande		269
4	bride		248
5	pthalogreen		237
6	Anonymous		232
7	sovereigna		191
8	denial_land		188
9	marikochan		180
10	sparkofcreation		166
11	ubykhlives		161
12	timwi		160
13	tungol		155
14	joyitude		154
15	asciident		141
16	muckefuck		140
17	n_true		130
18	ladyortyger		128
19	missysedai		126
20	entirelysonja		111
21	angelsk		103
22	opal1159		102
23	robnorth		98
24	leora		96
25	fledchen		91
26	darth_spacey		90
27	lexabear		87
28	fridoline		86
29	nyssa		84
30	nitaq		81
31	jordik		78
32	pleiades829		78
33	wingflutter		77
34	node_ue		75
35	allegrox		74
36	subbes		73
37	conuly		70
38	schnurble		69
39	lovewithnoface		69
40	jpallan		68
41	karen2205		66
42	angharad		66
43	nassus		61
44	bluewingedcat		61
45	fishgreenlittle		61
46	volantwish		61
47	kamara		57
48	fweebles		53
49	cadenzamuse		53
50	arthur_sc_king		51
51	afuna		48
52	mendel		47
53	haela		47
54	nou		47
55	lnbw		43
56	eilanhp		42
57	jc		40
58	it0376		39
59	swelegant		39
60	aajwind		38
61	crschmidt		35
62	noidd		34
63	christine		34
64	lied_ohne_worte		32
65	kait_the_great		32
66	ifeedformula		31
67	sedesdraconis		29
68	dampscribbler		28
69	meeps_hitchie		27
70	livredor		27
71	eridanusus		27
72	suomi_fani		25
73	musicus		24
74	uon		23
75	bacskocky		23
76	anicca_anicca		23
77	catamorphism		23
78	bicoherent		21
79	xtremesaints		20
80	rozallin		19
81	sarah_cb		19
82	isabeau		19
83	squigglz		18
84	kutsuwamushi		18
85	rho		17
86	otana		17
87	sphyg		17
88	alsatia		17
89	hidden_kitten		17
90	nondescript		17
91	jane_a		17
92	tonytraductor		16
93	thedward		16
94	spongebobjess		16
95	whimemsz		16
96	signal11		15
97	brad		14
98	edricson		14
99	camomiletea		14
100	fraught		13
101	ghewgill		12
102	ewx		12
103	rahaeli		12
104	me_and		11
105	damned_colonial		11
106	alister		10
107	rick_day		10
108	vittorio23		10
109	ibneko		10
110	tinyjo		10
111	danceinacircle		10
112	weatherpixie		9
113	util		9
114	ali_in_london		9
115	sjcarpediem		9
116	blob		9
117	pauraque		9
118	bobert225		8
119	diffrentcolours		8
120	psitticism		8
121	papertygre		7
122	redfarmer		7
123	ataltane		7
124	gothiclord_nick		6
125	tianamalla		6
126	tisoi		6
127	will21cn		6
128	ilia_yasny		6
129	earle		6
130	lt_black_fire		6
131	tamar		6
132	caelum		6
133	sandypar		6
134	zompist		6
135	relax_sven		5
136	remi_jakovlevic		5
137	neo_rowen		5
138	osnadurtha		5
139	ellakhne_puge		5
140	sea_sensu_si		5
141	jennielynn1127		5
142	nakedcelt		5
143	lydiabutterfly		5
144	supersat		4
145	clarkcox3		4
146	broca		4
147	shashin		4
148	boyzici		4
149	lyssiae		4
150	davorg		4
151	intrepia		4
152	emilyzilch		4
153	xaosenkosmos		4
154	purple_pen		4
155	tomato_chan		4
156	shm_revouse		4
157	wodentoad		4
158	youki		4
159	yueni		4
160	blech		4
161	zach		4
162	fire4ice		3
163	lysora		3
164	squixy		3
165	tysolna		3
166	so_haleza_grise		3
167	polarbee		3
168	enp		3
169	karteza		3
170	spodlife		3
171	chaotic_lady		3
172	lostinemotion		3
173	gw_columbia		3
174	burr86		3
175	lasher		3
176	deflatermouse		3
177	futurebird		3
178	pdcawley		3
179	zeev		3
180	komsip		3
181	positivenothing		3
182	vampwillow		3
183	none_too_subtle		3
184	joliecanard		3
185	bdot		3
186	bitterlight		3
187	beginning		3
188	hashbangperl		3
189	bopeepsheep		3
190	setone		2
191	hawkida		2
192	silverfiligree		2
193	jegrasso		2
194	persimmon		2
195	wapogipo88		2
196	spatulistic		2
197	ex_paranoidi324		2
198	spamsink		2
199	seaofdestiny		2
200	ghoti		2
201	nerosmaster		2
202	gabrielascrib		2
203	lampetia		2
204	ciaran_h		2
205	ex_hanniblfa747		2
206	declaude		2
207	chelle86		2
208	lorelei_aisling		2
209	bc_		2
210	oilf		2
211	blenrock		2
212	zooplah		2
213	adiekit		2
214	wolf_shadow		2
215	webdiva		2
216	zcitwi		2
217	cedara		2
218	ninebelow		2
219	smogo		2
220	insel		2
221	maltagirl		2
222	destruir		2
223	animate_mush		2
224	idigital		2
225	senji		2
226	mactavish		2
227	frankiawesome		2
228	jdm314		2
229	maycontain		2
230	solri		2
231	elusis		2
232	vrode		2
233	crayolaab		2
234	damerell		2
235	thethirdvoice		2
236	2shortplanks		2
237	romanticboy		2
238	feste		2
239	x_dingbat_x		2
240	wyntarvox		2
241	phoenixdreaming		2
242	coretta		2
243	crucially		2
244	pieceofpi		2
245	sheepthief		2
246	n2kaja		1
247	strictly_belle		1
248	oddthomas73		1
249	aliciagayle		1
250	kunar		1
251	xlcus		1
252	thewildrose		1
253	ibitsu		1
254	mauina		1
255	coffeechica		1
256	miaa		1
257	pseudomonas		1
258	beppergirl		1
259	pneling		1
260	gerg		1
261	bertho		1
262	atdelphi		1
263	matt_arnold		1
264	g_l_k		1
265	maaya6874		1
266	eclipses		1
267	walisongo		1
268	brian_barker		1
269	edge_walker		1
270	lovesasa		1
271	krakri		1
272	toturi		1
273	mercuriosity		1
274	skorpionuk		1
275	_etaoinshrdlu		1
276	tylendel		1
277	littlepthalo		1
278	teshiron		1
279	antaine		1
280	valentit_love9		1
281	viciousdisorder		1
282	esteil		1
283	jshado_1		1
284	germaniac_z		1
285	sisyphus238		1
286	kiss_me_quick		1
287	raventhon		1
288	bjorng		1
289	erincam		1
290	marsbee28		1
291	linnapaw		1
292	angiwyn		1
293	yak_boy		1
294	lucretia_fly		1
295	lavienverr		1
296	isiscolo		1
297	elvenshoo		1
298	reykr		1
299	anjori		1
300	billg		1
301	fukuniji		1
302	exor674		1
303	shakeyshake		1
304	styleygeek		1
305	msflutterbye		1
306	celestialweasel		1
307	eviepeevie		1
308	hopperpass		1
309	kthnxbi		1
310	akinabud		1
311	asc2		1
312	ceirdwenfc		1
313	supraek		1
314	pantsmanticore		1
315	circumstances		1
316	nyxie		1
317	enaron		1
318	___anomaly___		1
319	bluej100		1
320	colbymulkey		1
321	lukeii		1
322	rydel23		1
323	blackfyr		1
324	cadetdru		1
325	f0zzie		1
326	inannu		1
327	lea_9		1
328	jalbobble		1
329	sharon72		1
330	popcultureicon		1
331	marnameow		1
332	_korpsy_		1
333	sc00ter		1
334	pianodude34		1
335	pageman		1
336	lacey		1
337	stupid_freshman		1
338	sasha79		1
339	clnolen		1
340	twirlandswirl		1
341	lobosolo		1
342	mortaine		1
343	clarelass		1
344	sakura_no_kage		1
345	mr_eleganza		1
346	ptc24		1
347	dalryaug		1
348	angrychicken		1
349	dcpenguin		1
350	the_cynic		1
351	reclamationzone		1
352	kels		1
353	perfectstar		1
354	grimweaver		1
355	tenou_k		1
356	serge2000		1
357	rizen		1
358	daniele		1
359	indiwent		1
360	tammy		1
361	mordantliquor		1
362	richardthinks		1
363	kaiz0r		1
364	rfjason		1
365	alittleshy		1
366	dan4th		1
367	softdelusion		1
368	imagine2004		1
369	obie		1
370	spaced00d		1
371	la_perte		1
372	diesari		1
373	grey1618		1
374	helltosell		1
375	ext_83738		1
376	scjody		1
377	dubiant		1
378	emmavescence		1
379	simmiesworld		1
380	acerbic		1
381	chriswizard		1
382	imaria		1
383	codeman38		1
384	tbone		1
385	billchapman		1
386	linear_flower		1
387	pw201		1
388	genghis_gerbil		1
389	nycheetah		1
390	apel		1
391	lilblondepri333		1
392	madcaptenor		1
393	me1isa83		1
394	jinx_of_2ndlaw		1
395	thebrokentj		1
396	maetang		1
397	stegzy		1
398	jameth		1
399	sobrique		1
400	gragathaz		1
401	juuro		1
402	zzzayac		1
403	marvar		1
404	thestarsglowdim		1
405	ryf		1
406	ursamajor		1
407	blue_hours_too		1
408	dissolveddreams		1
409	schwarzer_tod		1
410	homicide_afp		1
411	tamtech		1
412	melinkasua		1
413	darsys		1
414	runeon		1
415	jheya		1

Generated by LJ Comment Stats.

Comments

[muckefuck.livejournal.com]

Last time I ran that script, I got wildly inaccurate results. How confident are you that this presents a reasonable snapshot of your commentors? (Take that, asciident! 15th place is mine!)

[pne.livejournal.com]

Not very - I'd be surprised if nik_w really was the #2 commenter or if bicoherent (a username I don't recognise and that's now deleted) posted 21 comments.

Perhaps I should just crunch the numbers myself.

[pne.livejournal.com]

Although a quick spot-check of a couple of entries implied that they're plausible, so perhaps the numbers aren't that inaccurate after all.

Odd that they don't match my impression, though.

[pne.livejournal.com]

Heh, I just got the paranoid idea that the meme might just be a nefarious way of garnering user-ID-to-username mappings, since LiveJournal users are otherwise hard to enumerate.

[ubykhlives.livejournal.com]

Grrr. Just outside the top 10. :)

Your journal seems to be awfully popular!

[pne.livejournal.com]

Certainly popular enough that I had to download the raw comment data in two goes since it would only give me 10'000 at once :)

[nik-w.livejournal.com]

Try using the program that I use - you can remove yourself, anonymous posters, and also it allows usermapping - so if you changed your name to "pne2", I could "symlink" pne to pne2 to total the result :)

I do comment quite a lot on your entries, though rarely saying anything particularly useful!:p

[pne.livejournal.com]

Which program do you use?

Also, for normal renaming, the tool I used will do the right thing because LiveJournal does in the basic data -- for example, "aquariumgirl" changed her name to aquariumgirl recently, and though she hasn't commented with that new name yet, all her comments are attributed to that name.

But there are at least two commenters who "renamed" by deleting their old journal and starting a new one, for whom mapping might be interesting.

[afuna]

Just outside the top 50!

Do you suppose billg is really Bill Gates?

[reykr.livejournal.com]

I picked the word "reykr," from Old Norwegian, to make it easy to find my blog, just by googling it. I've noticed that Chinese and Japanese bloggers, among others, have started using that word, too.

Today, by googling "Reykr," I ran across your ranking of "most prolific" commentators, and found that my blog was 298. Looking around the vicinity, I found a "billg" at 300, and he seems to be, or at least pretends to be, Bill Gates. It would be pretty funny, if he really was!

Jerry Baker

I see that the "billg" journal is a fake.

[reykr.livejournal.com]

I was getting cramped, from sitting at my computer desk last night, and quit before checking out "billg." I see, this morning, that the writer admits to having a fake journal.

JB